| ||||
|
|
Reader Letter 8/29/09
Hi,
I am writing to say that I support exposing pill-pushing
psychiatry as a farce, but I believe you have confused psychology with it.
Psychology is not the enemy here. There are dynamics in relationships that
it is sometimes necessary to understand in order to stop repeating the same
thing over and over. In my case the problem wasn't me but my mother. It
wasn't until I talked through what was going on with her that I finally
understood how the relationship worked. The Bible may call what she was
doing "gossip", but the psychological term is "triangulation"; she would
take what one of her adult children said and run to another expecting them
to take sides. I also didn't know how to stop it and still "honor" her. I
wanted to do the right thing, but what she was doing has driven wedges
between people and it needed to stop. I finally was able to tell her I was
no longer willing to listen to any issues she had with my brothers and
sisters; that it was hurtful and damaging.
That is the kind of tactful verbal skill I very much needed, but didn't get from Christian leaders. We need to teach the relationship skills to children; how are we to "be wise" in this area unless someone teach us? I agree the Bible provides the foundation, but not everything is in there. Not everyone is able to put words together easily to couch it in such a manner and still honor one's parent; I dealt with verbal and emotional abuse from my mother for 55 years. I don't know what you would have told me to do, but if Christians cannot understand that we all carry wounds from the past that need healing, or issues that dealing with and how to do it, who will? Doesn't Scripture tell us to be kind and tenderhearted to one another? Aren't we to weep with those who weep?
Please reconsider your attack on psychology (the study of
human behavior). I would agree that sin is the root, but we deal with each
other on a verbal level that does need understanding the church is not
providing the skills for.
Our
Response:
We understand your points, but you may be confusing psychology with communication skills, which we agree, the church needs to teach more of - being able to communicate with tact and kindness, but still set proper expectations and consequences if those expectations are not met. This is not what characterizes the majority of psychology. Psychology is the study of the soul, and a college undergrad / graduate education in it will indoctrinate you with various, conflicting man-made theories about why people think and behave the way they do, how to change them, and the goals of change. The Bible sufficiently addresses these areas (which are frequently polar opposite to psychology's views), as we discuss at length in our book "Psychology Debunked." Over time, the nature of our newsletters has taken a more psychiatric direction, because we see the damage done with psychiatry is more prevalent in the church these days than psychology, although both are damaging.
Also, when you read our book and
review our materials, you will see we are not debunking the psychology field
as a whole, but more specifically psychotherapy and psychiatric drugs. There
are legitimate studies in learning psychology, industrial psychology, etc.
that have little to do with relationships with God and others and the care
of the soul, which the Bible adequately addresses.
There are many cases where
psychology is correct in identifying behaviors, only because it is
parrotting what the Bible teaches, in its own lingo ("triangulation" and
"gossip," to take your example below). So why not just become expert on the
Bible, instead of mixing the world's philosophies in with it (Col. 2:8-10)?
We hope this helps clarify our
position on psychology and psychiatry, and thank you for writing.
Ryan and Lisa Bazler
|
|